literature

Simplification

Deviation Actions

Nichrysalis's avatar
By
Published:
748 Views

Literature Text

How does the cicada know
After seventeen years of maturation
To burrow itself

Into the trunks of trees
If it has only tasted roots?

How does the cicada know
To shelter and unshelter itself
As if it were

Domestic violence under a tin roof
That goes over a young boy's head.
You have questions.



Critique and feedback for #theWrittenRevolution:

:bulletyellow: Is the poem too short? Does it need more setup before the closing lines?
:bulletyellow: Does the cicada analogy set up the poem sufficiently? Should it be expanded upon?
:bulletyellow: How are the line breaks and stanza breaks?
:bulletyellow: What is your opinion if the lines were shorter and more even with each other?
:bulletyellow: Do the closing lines read faster than the rest of the poem to you? Does this seem good or bad to you?



© 2012 Nic Swaner
Comments6
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
CJWilde's avatar
:star::star::star::star::star-half: Overall
:star::star::star::star::star: Vision
:star::star::star::star::star-half: Originality
:star::star::star::star::star: Technique
:star::star::star::star::star-empty: Impact

I thoroughly enjoyed this piece (which is saying a lot, because you know I'm not much of a poetry person). I like things short, fast and hard-hitting, which is why this came as a pleasant surprise in my message centre. It was the initial imagery that sucked me in - if it has only tasted roots? - and how it left me wondering exactly why a cicada does what it does. Actually, it left me on Wikipedia. The end image was beautiful and perfectly timed.

I did feel the pace of the poem was appropriate; as I mentioned, I do like a short and to-the-point piece that will still leave you deep in thought. There's a talent to it. I felt the first three stanzas and the cicada anthology were of a nice length, well-paced, and set up the subject matter nicely. However, the ending itself was rather abrupt (wonderful and evocative as it was) and if I'm being picky, I'd say a line or two more to stipulate, or just emphasise, the point you are making might be something to think about. I would have liked to know what the final two lines were before *riparii's comment. As for the pace, the last two lines were a little faster but it didn't have any detrimental effect on the piece overall.

Regarding the hardware (form, grammar; I'm a geek in all walks) I found your use of punctuation and line breaks well placed. I personally would have not capitalised each line - I like a short piece to read a little quicker - but that's personal preference, and I'm familiar with your classic style. If there's one thing I don't want you to change, it's the line lengths and where you have placed the breaks. It works like this.

I also like the breaks after To burrow itself and As if it were. It emphasises the bare bones of the questions the reader is supposed to be asking themself. Hell, the second stanza stuck in my mind like glue. Irritating, jealous glue. Wikipedia, remember? Overall, really great piece. I always enjoy reading your work and this was no exception. <img src="e.deviantart.net/emoticons/a/a…" width="15" height="15" alt=":aww:" title="Aww"/>